StayCurrentMD · Telementoring panel discussion: Comparative Technology in Telementoring 2016
Video13 min·Published Sep 2016Older

Telementoring panel discussion: Comparative Technology in Telementoring 2016

With Dr. Todd Ponsky · hosted by Dr. Todd Ponsky
Try
Intelligent Search· scoped to this video · not medical adviceSearch the whole library →
What the experts said19 expert statements · 4 host summaries
Google Glass has been off the market for approximately one year as of this discussion
ClinicalBrian
Google Glass form factor allows wireless 3G/4G connectivity without fixed room infrastructure
ClinicalBrian
Google Glass cannot effectively illustrate tissue planes and enable fine telestration detail for surgical guidance on where to dissect and cut
ClinicalBrian
Lower fidelity but more scalable technology may be appropriate for later stages of progressive surgical training after initial observation and supervised cases
OpinionBrian
Google Glass battery life was approximately 15 minutes for recording or operative use
ClinicalBrian
Heat buildup on the head was a limitation of Google Glass during extended use
ClinicalBrian
Pristine company stripped down Google Glass operating system to extend battery life and decrease heat buildup
ClinicalBrian
For meaningful surgical cases, Google Glass required wired connection to external battery pack
ClinicalBrian
Europe will face a similar surgeon shortage to the United States
OpinionKnut
Surgical telementoring may decrease the length of surgical education
OpinionKnut
To become board certified in the United States, surgeons must take written or oral tests, but no one checks if they are good surgeons
ClinicalTodd Ponsky
The American Board of Surgery originally included observation of surgeons operating in their examination process
ClinicalSteve
Surgeon mentality is one of the biggest hurdles to telementoring adoption, including reluctance to show weakness or ask for help
OpinionTodd Ponsky
Having a mentor or advisor physically present in the operating room improves patient outcomes
ClinicalTodd Ponsky
Policymakers view telemedicine primarily as direct patient interaction for care delivery and do not understand telementoring as a quality initiative
OpinionBrian
There is a lack of good quality studies on surgical telementoring due to logistical obstacles and cumbersome technology
EpidemiologicalKnut
An international surgical quality registry for telementoring cases could generate meaningful evidence in 10 years rather than through small series of 10-20 cases
OpinionKnut
Medical-legal concerns and fear prevent widespread telementoring adoption and limit case volume for research
OpinionTodd Ponsky
Licensing and credentialing frameworks must be established before surgeons will feel comfortable performing telementored cases at scale
OpinionTodd Ponsky
64% of audience poll respondents believe the mentor should not have a prior relationship with the patient
Host summaryTodd Ponsky summarizing the discussion · not cited in answers
A recently published paper projects a shortage of 2,000 to 3,000 general surgeons in the United States within a few years
Host summaryKnut summarizing the discussion · not cited in answers
Residents finishing residencies need mentoring in their first two years of independent practice
Host summaryTodd Ponsky summarizing the discussion · not cited in answers
Patient outcome is directly related to surgeon technical ability
Host summaryBrian summarizing the discussion · not cited in answers